12 U.S. 46
Pine Brook, NJ 07058

Get Directions

Sales: 855-213-8302

Used Cars: 855-215-7372

Hours Toggle

Sales Department

Sun Closed
Mon 9:00am – 8:00pm
Tue 9:00am – 8:00pm
Wed 9:00am – 8:00pm
Thu 9:00am – 8:00pm
Fri 9:00am – 8:00pm
Sat 9:00am – 7:00pm

Service Department

Sun Closed
Mon 7:30am – 7:00pm
Tue 7:30am – 7:00pm
Wed 7:30am – 7:00pm
Thu 7:30am – 7:00pm
Fri 7:30am – 6:00pm
Sat 7:30am – 4:00pm

Reviews of Paul Miller Toyota of West Caldwell

Overall Rating:

4.7 (out of 5)

93% recommend this dealer

1179 total reviews

Showing the most recent reviews from Cars.com and DealerRater.

3.0 (out of 5)

Came for oil change and tire rotation.

Reviewed by ToyotaownerFebruary 14, 2026

Came for oil change and tire rotation. Fast and they include car wash. Not happy with Kevin that he would not honor Costco auto discount on the tire rotation cost. But the service manager finally gave discount. Just go to another service writer.

  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair

Overall Experience 3

Customer Service N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Friendliness N/A

Pricing N/A

Maximum rating = 5

2.0 (out of 5)

This review is strictly about the service dept.

Reviewed by Taco57 from Livingston, NJFebruary 12, 2026

This review is strictly about the service dept. which i found to be 100% against the consumer. The 1st item is as soon as you meet a service advisor, there a paper signs advising if you have a coupon for a discount, you must have the coupon with you. My service advisor was nice and he accepted the coupon from my phone. It was downhill from there. I requested and paid for an oil change and Multi Point inspection. In addition PM was to wash my car upon completion of the service. Since my appt was for after 5 PM, the car wash personnel leave at 5 PM and they did not advise I could come back another time. A few days after the oil change I noticed the oil was leaking. My vehicle was not leaking prior to being serviced. In addition my vehicle was close to 6 yrs old with the original battery. I then realized they never did the MP inspection since they never checked the battery. I went back to get the oil leak fixed and mentioned the old battery. Upon my return visit after mentioning the battery issue they did check the battery, advised it need to be changed, and wanted $300. i said no at the time but i called the service manger who advised he would get back to me. He did call me and advised there was an issue with the service and they would install the battery at their cost if I wanted to purchase a new battery and I should get back to him. After 5 to 10 calls he never called me back. New battery from Costco for $130 and never return to PM Toyota.

  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
  • Did not make a purchase

Overall Facilities N/A

Customer Service N/A

Buying Process N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Maximum rating = 5

5.0 (out of 5)

Top quality service, treated me right at every point -

Reviewed by MattFebruary 10, 2026

Top quality service, treated me right at every point - knowledgeable and reliable professionals through and through

  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair

Dealer Response

Matt, thank you for sharing your feedback about our team! You made our day at Paul Miller Toyota!

Overall Experience 5

Customer Service N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Friendliness N/A

Pricing N/A

Maximum rating = 5

About Paul Miller Toyota of West Caldwell

Located in Essex County NJ and serving nearby Morris County Toyota customers and Passaic County New Jersey Toyota customers Paul Miller Toyota is your source for Toyota Cars Trucks SUV's and Hybrid automobiles. Previously Caldwell Toyota and now under the ownership of Paul Miller Auto Group Paul Miller Toyota is one of the leading Toyota dealerships in the Northeast. If honest deals and fantastic customer service are what you're looking for than Paul Miller Toyota of New Jersey should be your Toyota Dealership of choice.

Ready to buy? Get a price quote before visiting the dealership.

  • Get multiple quotes
  • No cost, no-hassle negotiation
Back to Top