8941 E. US Highway 36
Avon, IN 46123

Get Directions

Sales: 317-548-1213

Used Cars: 317-548-1213

Hours Toggle

Sales Department

Sun Closed
Mon 8:30am – 8:00pm
Tue 8:30am – 8:00pm
Wed 8:30am – 8:00pm
Thu 8:30am – 8:00pm
Fri 9:00am – 6:00pm
Sat 9:00am – 6:00pm

Service Department

Sun Closed
Mon 7:30am – 6:00pm
Tue 7:30am – 6:00pm
Wed 7:30am – 6:00pm
Thu 7:30am – 6:00pm
Fri 7:30am – 6:00pm
Sat 8:00am – 2:00pm

Reviews of Andy Mohr Toyota

Overall Rating:

3.4 (out of 5)

83% recommend this dealer

858 total reviews

Showing the most recent reviews from Cars.com and DealerRater.

2.0 (out of 5)

So I got scammed when we financed our Tacoma from Andy

Reviewed by Lynda from Greencastle INJanuary 10, 2026

So I got scammed when we financed our Tacoma from Andy Mohr now I can’t get warranty work done. We had a sensor issue with the rear sliding window. We took it in and they said it will be a while to get the part. We will call you when it comes in. Of course never hear anything for a nine months. In the area today and stop in to check on it. No record. Work completed when vehicle was brought in originally. No record of part ordered or anything. Now it will be a charge to fix. Scammers in service too. Collected on warranty work but work not completed. Won’t expect anything different out of good old Andy Mohr Toyota.

  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
  • Did make a purchase

Dealer Response

We’re very sorry to hear you feel that way, Lynda. Our General Manager would be happy to speak with you so that he can get to the bottom of what went wrong here. His name is Ben Mendoza and he can be reached at your convenience at bmendoza@andymohr.com.

Overall Facilities N/A

Customer Service N/A

Buying Process N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Maximum rating = 5

1.0 (out of 5)

Unprofessional management and poor service.

Reviewed by TherecanonlybeonehighlanderJanuary 04, 2026

Unprofessional management and poor service. Went for a service job scheduled my appointment a week in advance and called the day before to make sure everything was OK before going in. I dropped my car off speaking with service helper named Nerri. Explained to me it was no problem and would take only 2 hours. He mentioned to me that they were apparently 6 cars behind. I said no worries just call me when its ready. I waited 2 hours and got the call to be told they made a mistake. The part ordered for service was never ordered somehow even tho before the appointment it was checked in inventory and green lighted. I demanded to speak to a manger, and was put on hold to be hung up on and then texted that they'll call me shortly. As im on my way to retrieve my vehicle the manger tells me " so we have this story " , but this is no story and this is not a manger who is doing thier job. As they crash out on me on the phone and ask me " what do you want me to do here." This shop is a joke , this was my second experience of using them in 6 months time. The first time was an oil change on my 2004 highlander. There was a 2025 grand highlander had the same thing done parked next to mine. As the owner drove out I watched 6 or more quarts of oil spill out the forgotten drain plug and watched them drive out and down the street. Should have never came back but sadly I did. Stay away from this stealership and thier Unprofessional service station unless you want to pay thousands in repairs or have your vehicle held against you.

  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair

Dealer Response

This doesn’t sound right to us, and our Service Manager would be happy to speak with you again to see if we're able to get this cleared up. His name is Tim Scully and he can be reached directly at tscully@andymohr.com.

Overall Experience 1

Customer Service N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Friendliness N/A

Pricing N/A

Maximum rating = 5

1.0 (out of 5)

I visited the dealer a few days before Halloween.

Reviewed by cobe_modelNovember 13, 2025

I visited the dealer a few days before Halloween. I liked a car, and a sales representative named Jeff Velasquez offered a 2025 RAV 4 Limited for $38,000. I was still undecided about the deal. I finally had a day off yesterday, Veterans Day. I called and got confirmation that the price was still the same. I went in to test the car and wanted to trade in my car as part of the purchase. They offered a very low price for my trade-in until I showed them the report from CarMax. They raised the offer a bit and explained the tax implications before and after the trade. I was aware of how it worked. Then they raised the price further. What a rip-off. You don't want to waste your time with this sales representative or his manager, who tried to convince me to come in for a test drive and made me wait. It was a complete waste of time. Their customer service is very poor, and they blatantly BIG LIED to customers like me.

  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a new car

Dealer Response

We appreciate you sharing your take on the situation. We offered you our best price on the vehicle, and we’re sorry that we weren’t able to come to an agreement.

Overall Experience 1

Customer Service N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Friendliness N/A

Pricing N/A

Maximum rating = 5

About Andy Mohr Toyota

Our large inventory and wide selection of models along with competitive pricing allow us to make you a great deal on the Toyota of your choice. At Andy Mohr Toyota our goal is to assist you in making a confident decision. Our friendly professional staff members are here to answer your questions and listen to your needs. Whether you're shopping for a new or pre-owned vehicle we're here to help with your search. Our well-stocked inventory includes popular Toyota models including Camry Corolla and Highlander. Wherever you live in the Indianapolis area or if you're driving from Carmel Greenwood Fishers or Carmel we're ready to serve you.

Ready to buy? Get a price quote before visiting the dealership.

  • Get multiple quotes
  • No cost, no-hassle negotiation
Back to Top