305 Sunrise Hwy
Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Get Directions
Hours Toggle

Sales Department

Sun 11:00am – 5:00pm
Mon 9:00am – 8:00pm
Tue 9:00am – 8:00pm
Wed 9:00am – 8:00pm
Thu 9:00am – 8:00pm
Fri 9:00am – 6:00pm
Sat 9:00am – 6:00pm

Service Department

Sun Closed
Mon 7:30am – 5:00pm
Tue 7:30am – 5:00pm
Wed 7:30am – 5:00pm
Thu 7:30am – 5:00pm
Fri 7:30am – 5:00pm
Sat 7:30am – 5:00pm

Reviews of South Shore Subaru

Showing the most recent reviews from Cars.com and DealerRater.

1.0 (out of 5)

The most dishonest dealership, I have ever dealt with in

Reviewed by Allan Jones from Point Pleasant New Jersey September 30, 2025

The most dishonest dealership, I have ever dealt with in my life. I purchased the car on July 14 for my son. They sold me the car illegally without having the proper documentation for me to title the car. I am still waiting to have this car titled. every time I call, they simply say to me we’ll have it next week. If I leave a message, nobody gets back to me. They have left me no other option than to file a complaint with the Attorney General‘s office in New York. The car is sitting in my driveway, I am paying insurance on the car for three months now, and my son cannot drive his car. I have even left messages with Nico Levine general manager twice he has never called me back the third time I called the receptionist went into his office with the phone and told him about the problem I was having he said it’s not his job and then they sent me to another number where nobody answers the phone. It’s sad this company is probably $1 billion company and they’re putting me through this for a $13,000 sale. I wish they would just take the car back give me my money so I could buy my son a car that he can drive.

  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase

Dealer Response

Allan, We’re sorry to hear about your frustration, and we understand how delays with vehicle registration can be incredibly inconvenient — especially when it's for your son. However, we must clarify several key facts: You purchased a vehicle with an out-of-state registration (New Jersey), and unfortunately, we are not in control of the New Jersey DMV's processing times. We've been in regular contact with NJ DMV and have kept you informed with each update they’ve provided us. We received confirmation that the vehicle has been titled and the plates and registration are en route to us. Once received, they will be immediately forwarded to you — which is standard procedure for all out-of-state deals. Your claim that no one has returned your calls is simply not true. You’ve been in direct contact with your salesperson, the used car manager, and the assistant to the used car manager throughout this process. Our team has made effort to keep you updated despite the delays being entirely outside of our control. Most concerning, however, is your accusation that I refused to assist you and claimed “it’s not my job.” This never happened. In fact, the scenario you described — where a receptionist allegedly walked a landline phone from the reception desk located in the front of our building all the way to my office , located towards the back of the building — is physically impossible. We take personal attacks on our staff very seriously, especially when they are entirely fabricated. We are committed to resolving every customer issue with professionalism and integrity. While we understand your frustration with DMV delays, making false and damaging claims is not only DEFAMING and unfair to myself and our staff — it’s also misleading to others reading this review. We will continue to follow procedure until the final documents are in your hands, and we remain available should you have any further questions.- Nico Levinas-General Manager

Overall Facilities N/A

Customer Service N/A

Buying Process N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Maximum rating = 5

5.0 (out of 5)

We recently bought a used Crosstrek and had a great

Reviewed by Erica B from Hoboken, NJJune 03, 2025

We recently bought a used Crosstrek and had a great experience working with Ben Sporn. He was incredibly knowledgeable and patient — helping us find the right pre-owned Crosstrek to fit our needs and looking diligently through his inventory until we found the perfect match. His communication was always clear and timely, and he made what can often be a stressful process feel easy and straightforward. From our first conversation to driving off the lot, everything ran smoothly. We’re really happy with both the car and the experience, and we’d absolutely recommend working with him if you’re in the market. He was friendly, honest, and clearly cares about helping people find the right vehicle.

  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase

Dealer Response

Erica, Thank you so much for your thoughtful and kind review! We're thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience working with Ben. It's wonderful to know that his knowledge, patience, and dedication helped make the process of finding your Crosstrek smooth and enjoyable. We truly valu e your trust in us and are so glad you're happy with both the vehicle and your overall experience. Ben will be delighted to hear your kind words. Thank you again for your recommendation, it means a great deal to us!- Nico Levinas- General Manager

Overall Facilities N/A

Customer Service N/A

Buying Process N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Maximum rating = 5

5.0 (out of 5)

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely!

Reviewed by Helen Aponte from Smithtown, NYDecember 04, 2024

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely! Here's an updated version of the review As I had mentioned to Matt Caridi, I am giving 10 stars!!! I had the pleasure of working with two amazing individuals at South Shore Subaru, and I can't express enough how grateful I am for their kindness and professionalism throughout my car-buying process. Matt Caridi is a young and energetic sales associate who was with me every step of the way. From providing detailed insights into the used 2021 Jeep Compass I was interested in, to assisting with the test drive, Matt’s enthusiasm and eagerness to help made the entire experience smooth and enjoyable. He went above and beyond by mentioning the dealer’s Exclusive VIP Plus Program—such a great perk! In addition to helping me with my purchase, Matt also showed great initiative in assisting a friend who was looking for a van for her business. He took the time to search for potential vehicles that would suit her needs, demonstrating his commitment to ensuring customers receive the best service possible. I truly appreciated his positive energy, care, and the effort he put into making sure I had all the information I needed to make an informed decision. His youthful energy was enjoyable! Mr. Anthony Salomone, the Used Car Sales Manager, was an absolute joy to work with. He was incredibly kind and patient, always making sure to offer the best deal possible. At one point, when the numbers weren't aligning, Mr. Salomone went above and beyond to call me back and try to work with me on a deal. Even when I couldn't provide the full payment right away due to circumstances outside of my control, he remained calm and understanding. What really stood out to me was his respect for my decision and faith. When I told him I trusted that the Lord would guide the process, he listened thoughtfully and gave me the space to follow through with my trust. His understanding and sincerity were a true testament to his character. Ultimately, I was able to purchase the car without any hassle, and when I arrived at the dealership to finalize everything, Mr. Salomone was as friendly and accommodating as ever. Even though the car was re-listed at a higher price, he didn’t make me feel pressured or take advantage of the situation. Instead, he simply asked when I would be there to complete the purchase, which made me feel respected and valued as a customer. The whole experience at South Shore Subary was refreshing. Matt and Mr. Salomone made what could have been a stressful process into something truly special. They both went out of their way to ensure that I was comfortable and satisfied, and I am so thankful for their support. Thank you, Matt and Mr. Salomone, for your outstanding service and kindness. I will certainly be recommending this dealership to friends and family. God bless you both!

  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase

Dealer Response

Helen, what can we say besides WOW! What a wonderful review to read! This is what it's all about for us. Providing memorable experiences in a business that's not known for it! We take great pride in being more than your typical car dealer. Your feedback concerning your experience is a true testament to what we strive to accomplish with all of our clients. Thank you for leaving such amazing feedback. We look forward to being there for you, for the years to come. Enjoy your vehicle! We wish you many safe and happy miles ahead- Nico Levinas- General Manager

Overall Facilities N/A

Customer Service N/A

Buying Process N/A

Quality of Repair N/A

Maximum rating = 5

About South Shore Subaru

South Shore Subaru offers America's #1 VIP program including a Free Service loaners Free oil changes Free 24/7 Rescue Express Lane Oil changes and the most convenient service hours in the business. We offer a huge selection of new and certified pre-owned vehicles. So now you know why...now check out our what our customer say after they have purchased from us!! Will Satisfy You!!

Ready to buy? Get a price quote before visiting the dealership.

  • Get multiple quotes
  • No cost, no-hassle negotiation
Back to Top