2015 BMW 428 vs. 2016 Cadillac ATS Review

Comparison Review

The BMW 428 offers a bit more room for passengers in the back seat than the Cadillac ATS. The BMW 428 will be a favorite with taller drivers due to its greater front head- and legroom than the Cadillac ATS.

The BMW 428 will require fewer stops at the gas station than the Cadillac ATS, making it more convenient to drive.

There are a lot of factors to consider when calculating the overall cost of a vehicle. The main consideration is Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). When looking only at MSRP, the BMW 428 will have less of an impact on your bank account than the Cadillac ATS. Another consideration is the Destination Charge, which is a standard charge for transporting the vehicle to the dealer from where it's built. The BMW 428 and the Cadillac ATS have similar Destination Charges.

The BMW 428 is about the same width as the Cadillac ATS. When looking at overall length, the BMW 428 takes up about the same amount of space in your garage as the Cadillac ATS.

With its lower torque, the BMW 428 doesn't do as good a job transmitting power to its wheels as the Cadillac ATS.

The BMW 428 has about the same turning radius as the Cadillac ATS, allowing equal maneuverability in and out of tight spots.

The BMW 428 has less horsepower than the Cadillac ATS, so it will probably be somewhat slower.

In terms of seating you'll be able to fit the same number of people in both the BMW 428 and the Cadillac ATS. With its significantly greater cargo capacity, the BMW 428 will be able to haul more equipment or luggage than the Cadillac ATS.

The BMW 428 comes with essentially the same basic warranty as the Cadillac ATS.

Watch Video

Compare the 2015 BMW 428 and the 2016 Cadillac ATS.

Get your best price before going to the dealer!

2015 BMW

More Details & Photos New 2015 BMW 428
MSRP*: $40,750 - $42,750

2016 Cadillac

More Details & Photos New 2016 Cadillac ATS
MSRP*: $37,995 - $51,945
Cash Back Rebate: Visit Rebate Center Up to $750
Low APR Loan: -- As low as 0.00%
Lease Incentive: -- --
City MPG: 22 - 23 19 - 22
Highway MPG: 33 - 35 28 - 31
Engine(s): Inline-4 Inline-4, V-6
Seating Capacity: 4 - 4 4 - 4
Basic Warranty: 4 years/50,000 miles 4 years/50,000 miles
Invoice*: $37,990 - $39,830 $35,905 - $48,569

Days On Lot: Comparing Ease of Negotiation

Days on Lot measures the average number of days a model sits on a dealer's lot before it's sold. This is one predictor of a dealer's willingness to negotiate.

Monthly Trend for:
2015 BMW 428

No Days On Lot Data

No Data

Monthly Trend for:
2016 Cadillac ATS

No Days On Lot Data

No Data

Car Chooser

Still Deciding?

Use Car Chooser from to narrow your new car search by body type, price, make, fuel economy and much more!

Compare your contenders side by side and review the details of each new car you've filtered down to. See available styles, options, rebates and incentives for the models you're looking at.

There's no other tool quite like it!

*MSRP and Invoice prices displayed do not include applicable gas taxes or destination charges.